Carbon debt and the (in)significance of history; 346-365

(Full text in pdf format)


Pia Halme


University of Newcastle upon Tyne, UK


Abstract. My aim in this paper is to discuss the so-called (historical) carbon debt to see who should take responsibility for past carbon emissions and why, and indeed what role we should accord to history when looking for just allocation of duties to cover the costs associated with anthropogenic climate change. I shall argue that the beneficiary pays account, slightly modified, is the most promising approach. I also argue that carbon debt should not be interpreted as a call for reparations. Rather, what matters is restoring equality and this requires respecting the entitlements of all individuals to have their vital interests protected. Taking past emissions into account is significant insofar as it shows that the wealth of the affluent industrial countries is not morally protected as it is a consequence of activities that harm the entitlements of others.


Keywords: carbon debt, climate change, beneficiary pays, advantage, past emissions, reparations





Anderson, Elizabeth S. (1999) “What is the point of equality?”. Ethics 109, 2, 287–337.

Anderson, Jan Otto and Mattias Lindroth (2001) “Ecologically unsustainable trade”. Ecological Economics 37, 113–122.

Beitz, Charles R. (2001) “Does global inequality matter”. In Global justice, 106–122. Thomas W. Pogge, ed. Oxford: Blackwell.

Caney, Simon (2001) “Cosmopolitan justice and equalizing opportunities”. In Global justice, 123–144. Thomas W. Pogge, ed. Oxford: Blackwell.

Caney, Simon (2006a) “Cosmopolitan justice, rights and global climate change”. Canadian Journal of Jurisprudence 19, 2, 255–278.

Caney, Simon (2006b) “Environmental degradation, reparations, and the moral significance of history”. Journal of Social Philosophy 37, 3, 464–482.

Carter Alan (2002) “On harming others. A response to partridge”. Environmental Values 11, 87–96

Carter, Alan (2001) “Can we harm future people”. Environmental Values 10, 429–54.

Gosseries, Axel (2003) “Historical emissions and free-riding”. Penultimate version downloaded from: (8.9.2007). Article published 2004 in Ethical Perspectives 11, 1, 36–60.

Hayward, Tim (2005a) “Human rights vs emissions rights: climate justice and the equitable distribution of ecological space”, unpublished draft.

Hayward, Tim (2005b) “Thomas Pogge’s global resources dividend: a critique and an alternative”. Journal of Moral Philosophy 2, 3, 317–332.

Hinsch Wilfried (2001) “Global distributive justice”. In Global justice, 55–75. Thomas W. Pogge, ed. Oxford: Blackwell.

Kumar, Rahul (2003) “Who can be wronged?”. Philosophy & Public Affairs 31, 2, 99–118.

Living Planet Report 2006. Published in October 2006 by WWF-World Wide Fund For Nature (formerly World Wildlife Fund), Gland, Switzerland.

Meyer, Lukas H. (2001) “Transnational autonomy: responding to historical injustice in the case of the Saami and Roma Peoples”. International Journal on Minority and Group Rights 8, 263–301.

Neumayer, Eric (2000). “In defence of historical accountability for greenhouse gas emissions”. Ecological Economics 33, 185–92.

Nozick, Robert (1974) Anarchy, state, and utopia. Oxford: Blackwell.

Page, Edward A. (2006) Climate change, justice and future generations. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing.

Parfit, Derek (1986) Reasons and persons. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Parry M. L., O. F. Canziani, J. P. Palutikof, P. J. van der Linden, and C. E. Hanson, eds. (2007) Climate change 2007: impacts, adaptation and vulnerability. (Contribution of Working Group II to the Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change.) Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Pogge, Thomas W. (2004) “’Assisting’ the global poor”. In The ethics of assistance. Morality and the distant needy, 260–288. Deen K. Chatterjee, ed. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Shue, Henry (1993) “Subsistence emissions and luxury emissions”. Law & Policy 15, 1, 39–59.

Shue, Henry (1996) Basic rights. Subsistence, affluence, and U.S. foreign policy. 2nd ed. (First edition published 1980). Princeton: Princeton University Press.

Shue, Henry (1999) “Global environment and international inequity”. International Affairs 75, 3, 531–545.

Simms, Andrew (2001) An environmental war economy. The lessons of ecological debt and global warming. (A New Economics Foundation Pocketbook.) London: New Economics Founda­tion.

Simms, Andrew (2005) Ecological debt. The health of the planet & the wealth of nations. London: Pluto Press.

Stern, Nicholas (2007) The economics of climate change: the stern review. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Vanderheiden, Steve (2006) “Climate change, environmental rights, and emissions shares”. Paper prepared for delivery at the 2006 Western Political Science Association meeting. Depart­ments of Political Science & Philosophy, University of Duluth. Downloaded from:

Who owes who? Climate change, dept, equity and survival. Paper from Christian Aid, 1999.