TRAMES, 2007, 11(61/56), 2, 206222



(full text in pdf format)


Kulno Türk, Tõnu Roolaht


University of Tartu



Abstract. The performance appraisal and compensation aspects in the public and private universities are increasingly important. Even publicly funded universities have to seek for additional re­sources from private market and thus monitor and develop their performance accordingly. In public universities, the number of state-funded students has been decreas­ing rapidly, and the share of tuition fees has increased. Thus, public universities have been exposed to market pressures that require dynamic approaches similar to the changes implemented in private universities. The purpose of this study is to compare performance appraisal as well as compensation policies and systems in Estonian public and private universities in order to determine the possible differences. The results indicate no major appraisal or compensation differences between these two groups of universities. Yet, private universities seem to value student feedback and other market-driven appraisal aspects slightly more than public universities, who value more development interviews.


Keywords: performance appraisal, academic institutions, public vs. private





Annual Report of The University of Tartu 2002 (2003, 2004). Tartu.

Bellamy, Sheila, Clive Morley, and Kim Watty (2003) “Why business academics remain in Australian universities despite deteriorating working conditions and reduced job satisfaction: an intellectual puzzle”. Journal of Higher Education Policy & Management 25, 1, 13–28.

Boyd, Neil M. and Ken Kyle (2004) “Expanding the view of performance appraisal by introducing social justice concerns”. Administrative Theory & Praxis 26, 3, 249–277.

Brown, Michelle and John Benson (2003) “Rated to exhaustion? Reactions to performance appraisal processes”. Industrial Relations Journal 34, 1, 67–81.

Budhwar, Pawan S. and George Boyne (2004) “Human resource management in the Indian public and private sectors: an empirical comparison”. International Journal of Human Resource Management 15, 2, 346–370.

Chevaillier, Therry (2001) “French academics: between the professions and the civil service”. Higher Education 41, 1/2, 49–76.

Elliott, Kevin M. and Dooyoung Shin (2002) “Student satisfaction: an alternative approach to assessing this important concept”. Journal of Higher Education Policy & Management 24, 2, 197–209.

Fletcher, Clive (2001) “Performance appraisal and management: the developing research agenda”. Journal of Occupational & Organizational Psychology 74, 4, 473–487.

Gatfield, Terry, Michelle Barker, and Peter Graham (1999) “Measuring student quality variables and the implications for management practices in higher education institutions: an Australian and international student perspective”. Journal of Higher Education Policy & Management 21, 2, 239–260.

Grote, Dick (2000) “Public sector organizations”. Public Personnel Management 29, 1, 1–20.

Houston, Don and Malcolm Rees (1999) “Developing a quality management system for a post­graduate education programme: a case study”. Journal of Higher Education Policy & Manage­ment 21, 2, 227–238.

Longenecker, Clinton O. and L. Fink (1999) “Creating effective performance appraisal”. Industrial Management 41, 5, 18–26.

Mani, Bonnie G. (2002) “Performance appraisal systems, productivity, and motivation: a case study”. Public Personnel Management 31, 2, 141–59.

Mergen, E., D. Grant, and S. Widrick (2000) “Quality management applied to higher education”. Total Quality Management 11, 3, 345–353.

Pratt, M. and D. Margaritis (1999) “Developing a research culture in a university faculty”. Journal of Higher Education Policy & Management 21, 1, 43–57.

Scott, S. V. (1999) “The academic as service provider: is the customer ‘always right’?”. Journal of Higher Education Policy & Management 21, 2, 193–202.

Sinclair, Mark (2003) “Three futures for university provision: the social justice market, state capitalism and private for-profit universities”. Journal of Higher Education Policy & Management 25, 2, 161–171.

Smith, Brien N., Jeffrey S. Hornsby, and Roslyn Shirmeyer (1996) “Current trends in performance appraisal: an examination of managerial practice”. SAM Advanced Management Journal 61, 3, 10–15.

Stilwell, Frank (2003) “Higher education, commercial criteria and economic incentives”. Journal of Higher Education Policy & Management 25, 1, 51–61.

The Survey of Performance Appraisal in Estonian Universities, 2005 (survey data).

The Survey of Performance Appraisal in the Tartu FEBA, 2004 (survey data).

Willis, T. Hillmann and Albert J. Taylor (1999) “Total quality management and higher education: the employers’ perspective”. Total Quality Management 10, 7, 997–1000.