(full text in pdf format)


Ivan Svetlik1, Tőnu Kaarelson2, Ruth Alas2, Andrej Kohont1

1University of Ljubljana, 2Estonian Business School, Tallinn


Abstract. In international comparative studies of personnel management/HRM, one of the central issues is to identify similarities and differences in approaches to this specific function in organisations. The driving forces in a market economy lead HRM practices in different countries down more or less a similar path. In this case it is assumed that the best methods and practices that have proven themselves indeed exist, and these have therefore been found in use whereever a market economy works. The same trend is noticeable when talking about the influence of institutional forces in European Union that result in HRM practices becoming increasingly similar in different countries. At the same time, developments in HRM in different countries are influenced by deeply rooted value systems and cultural traditions that act as forces creating and maintaining divergence. The comparison of Slovenia and Estonia offers specific insights into how and why the HRM function has changed in organisations in two new European Union member countries.


Keywords: organisation, personnel management, human resource management, personnel function, personnel manager, personnel department, personnel policy





1.        Alas, R. and I. Svetlik, I. (2004) “Estonia and Slovenia: building modern HRM using a dualist approach”. In Human resource management in Europe: evidence of convergence? Brewster, C., W. Mayrhofer, and M. Morley, eds. Amsterdam, Boston, Heidelberg etc.: Elsevier Butterworth-Heinemannn.

2.        Barnowe, J. T., G. King, and E. Berniker (1992) “Personal values and economic transition in the Baltic States”. Journal of Baltic Studies 23, 2, 179–190.

3.        Beardwell, I. and L. Holden, eds. (2001) Human resource management: a comparative approach. Harlow, London, New York etc.: Financial Times and Prentice Hall.

4.        Becker, G. S. (1964) Human capital. New York: Columbia University Press for the National Bureau of Economic Research.

5.        Beer, M., B. Spector, P. R. Lawrence, D. Q. Mills, and R. E. Walton (1984) Managing human assets. New York and London: Macmillan Publishers.

6.        Brekiă, J. (1968) Kadrovska politika u samoupravnim odnosima. [Personnel policy in self-managing relations.] Zagreb: Informator.

7.        Brekiă, J. (1983) Kadrovska teorija i praksa. [Personnel policy and practice.] Zagreb: Informator.

8.        Brewster, C. and H. H. Larsen (1992) “Human resource management in Europe: evidence from the countries”. The International Journal of Human Resource Management  3, 3, 409–434.

9.        Cranet-E (s.a.) The Cranfield network for the study of human resource management in Europe. Cranfield University, School of Management.

10.     Department of Management and Planning (1986) Creation and development of the major in industry planning. Tallinn: TPI. (In Estonian.)

11.     Estonian Cranet Report (2004) Estonian Business School. Department of Management. (In Estonian.)

12.     Fayol, H. (1949) General and industrial management. London: Pitman.

13.     Gasparoviă, V. (1981) Personalna sluţba. [Personnel department.] Zagreb: Centar za proizvodnost.

14.     Herzberg, F. (1966) Work and the nature of man. New York: Crowell.

15.     Ignjatovič, M. and I. Svetlik (2005) “‘HRM of low intensity”. In HRM’s contribution to hard work. I. Svetlik and B. Ilič, eds. Bern, Berlin, Bruxelles, etc: Peter Lang.

16.     Kamuđič, M. (1972) Kadrovska funkcija in kadrovsko-socialne sluţbe. [Personnel function and personnel-social department.] Kranj: Zavod za izobraţevanje kadrov in proučevanje organizacije dela.

17.     Kamuđič, M. (1981) Izobrazbeni kadrovski profili, delovne zahteve, perspektive, potrebe in fleksibil­nost srednjeđolskih in visokođolskih kadrov. [Educational personnel profiles, work demands, perspectives, needs and flexibility of under and higher-educated cadres.] Ljubljana: VUĐ.

18.     Kavran, D. (1976) Kadrovska funkcija u udruţenom radu. [Personnel function in associated labour.] Beograd: Suvremena administracija.

19.     Laar, M. (2002) Eesti uus algus. [The new beginning of Estonia.] Tallinn: Tänapäev.

20.     Legge, K. (1978) Power, innovation and industrial management. London: McGraw-Hill.

21.     Likert, R. (1967) The human organisation. New York: McGraw-Hill.

22.     Liuhto, K. (1999) “The organisational and managerial transformation in turbulent business environ­ments: managers’ views on the transition of their enterprise in some of the European former Soviet Republics in the 1990’s”. Publications of the Turku School of Economics and Busi­ness Administration. Series A-9.

23.     Maslow, A. H. (1954) Motivation and personality. New York: Harper & Row.

24.     Mayo, E. (1933) The human problems of and industrial civilization. New York: Macmillan.

25.    Mayrhofer, W. and H. H. Larsen (2006) “European HRM: a distinct field of research and practice”. In Managing human resources in Europe: a thematic approach. H. H. Larsen and W. Mayr­hofer, eds. New York: Routledge.

26.     McGregor, D. (1960) The human side of enterprise. New York: McGraw Hill.

27.     Mesner-Andolđek, D. and J. Đtebe (2005) “The HRM function and line management in European organisations: how far has devolution gone?”. In HRM’s contribution to hard work. I. Svetlik and B. Ilič, eds. Bern, Berlin, Bruxelles, etc.: Peter Lang.

28.     Misiunas, R. J. and R. Taagepera (1983) The Baltic states: years of dependence, 1940-1980. London: Hurst; and Berkeley: University of California Press.

29.     Moţina, S. (1975) Kadrovska politika v pogojih samoupravljanja. [Personnel policy in self-managing conditions.] Kranj: Moderna organizacija.

30.     Paalberg, H. (1989) “On the origins of Soviet economic mechanism and the need for radical reform”. Journal of Baltic Studies 20, 2, 191–195.

31.     Palm, T. (1989) “Perestroika in Estonia: the cooperatives”. Journal of Baltic Studies 20, 2, 127–148.

32.     Rajasalu, T. (1995) ‘Macroeconomic stabilization and development”. In Transforming the Estonian Economy, 16–51. O. Lugus and G. A. Hachey, eds. Tallinn: Majanduse Instituut.

33.     Renwick, D. and M. C. MacNeil (2002) “Line manager involvement in careers”. Career Develop­ment 7, 7, 407–414.

34.     Rojot, J. (1990) “Human resource management in France”. In Human resource management: an international comparison. R. Pieper, ed. Berlin and New York: Walter de Gruyter.

35.     Schultz, T. W. (1978) Economic analysis of investment in education. Washington D. C.

36.     Skorobogatov, I. (1981)”Ways to reorganise personnel work”. In Problems of managerial innovation and economic experimentation. Pan-soviet scientific-practical conference. Tallinn, Volume 2, 252–257. (In Russian.)

37.     Springer, B. and S. Springer (1990) “Human resource management in the U.S.: celebration of its century’. In Human resource management: an international comparison. R. Pieper, ed. Berlin and New York: Walter de Gruyter.

38.     Svetlik, I., M. Pavliha, F. Aljaţ, I. Kejţar, M. Sekirica, and S. Sirc (1980) Naloge kadrovske dejavnosti v organizacijah zdruţenega dela. [Tasks of personnel function in associated labour organizations.] Ljubljana: CSND.

39.     Taaler, J. (1995) “Economic reforms: the main stages, programmes and evaluations”. In Trans­forming the Estonian economy, 1–15. O. Lugus and G. A. Hachey, eds. Tallinn: Majanduse Instituut.

40.     Taylor, F. W. (1911) Scientific management. New York: Harper & Row.

41.     Torrington, D. and L. Hall (1987) Personnel management: a new approach. New York, London, etc.: Prentice Hall.

42.     Tđiţov, E. and V. Tđurmantejeva (1975) “Theoretical and practical problems of personnel manage­ment”. In 4th conference on problems of managing economic organisations. Tallinn. (In Estonian.)

43.     Vanhala, S. (1995) “Human resource management in Finland”. Employee Relations (Bradford) 17, 7, 31–57.

44.     Venesaar, U. and E. Vitsur (1995) “Development of entrepreneurship”. In Transforming the Estonian Economy, 187–207. O. Lugus and G. A. Hachey, eds. Tallinn: Majanduse Inastituut.

45.     Zamascikov, S. (1987) “Soviet methods and instrumentalities of maintaining control over the Balts”. Journal of Baltic Studies 18, 3, 221–234.

46.     Zupan, N. (1999) Ravnanje s človeđkimi viri v slovenskih podjetjih. [Human resource management in Slovene enterprises.] Doktorska disertacija. Ekonomska fakulteta. Ljubljana.